College Football Playoff Selection Show Thread

[Gerry Hamilton]

Here we go. 

[Gerry Hamilton]

1. Indiana - as expected 

[Gerry Hamilton]

2. Ohio State 

[Gerry Hamilton]

3. Georgia 

[Gerry Hamilton]

4. Texas Tech 

[Gerry Hamilton]

5. Oregon 

[Gerry Hamilton]

6. Ole Miss - wild

[Gerry Hamilton]

7. Texas A&M

[Gerry Hamilton]

8. Oklahoma 

[Gerry Hamilton]

9. Alabama 

[Gerry Hamilton]

10. Miami 

 

Notre Dame is out

[TexasFanatic]

Ole Miss is going to play Tulane and they already beat the crap out of them 

[Texas fan in Georgia]

Conference title games are officially meaningless. Bama should’ve dropped. Now there’s what 2 rematches ? Glad ND got left out. Boy oh boy I’d love to see Marcus freeman right now

[Oskies1279]

That just shows how screwed up the system is. Alabama doesn't deserve to be in at 10-3 if byu is out. 

[TexasFanatic]

Will Texas play ND?

[Gerry Hamilton]

11. Tulane - rematch from 45-10 earlier this season 

[Gerry Hamilton]

12. James Madison 

[Gerry Hamilton]

1 minute ago, TexasFanatic said:

Will Texas play ND?

Should be Michigan in Citrus Bowl 

[horns96]

James Madison and Tulane in a playoff.  LMAO.

[Gerry Hamilton]

2 minutes ago, Oskies1279 said:

That just shows how screwed up the system is. Alabama doesn't deserve to be in at 10-3 if byu is out. 

System is definitely screwed up ... but 

Bama won at Georgia 

BYU has zilch, and would get dog walked at Georgia 

[Nathan Larson]

CFP makes no logic. ACC review has more clarity.

[Texas fan in Georgia]

The committee left BYU ahead of Texas. Just complete and utter bullshit man. Truly truly laughable

[horns96]

Sagarin's ratings have James Madison rated #28 and Tulane at #46.  Those aren't even top 25 teams, much less one of the 12 best.

Edited December 7, 2025 by horns96

[Oskies1279]

1 minute ago, Gerry Hamilton said:

System is definitely screwed up ... but 

Bama won at Georgia 

BYU has zilch, and would get dog walked at Georgia 

True, but if you're going to penalize byu by leaving them out due to a ccg loss then do the same with bama. Texas's record is a better 3 loss team, and should have been in over bama after that loss. The whole, "they beat Georgia", well Texas has beat a&m, ou, and vandy. Plus let's not forget that fsu loss is worse than Florida. 

[Ace Recruiter]

Including smaller schools makes sense in basketball not football. Scrap this model