OTF Premium Jelani McDonald is making opponents pay for targeting him in coverage

At some point, opposing quarterbacks must stop picking on Jelani McDonald.

According to Pro Football Focus, McDonald has been targeted 15 times in coverage through four games. That’s No. 1 among SEC safeties, and tied for 20th among FBS safeties, but McDonald has made teams pay for throwing in his direction.

McDonald has allowed eight receptions for 76 yards (9.5 yards per reception). With two interceptions (PFF also has him down for one dropped interception), McDonald has held opposing quarterbacks to a paltry 28.1 NFL passer rating when targeting him.

A dynamic athlete Texas recruited out of Waco Connally in the 2023 cycle, McDonald has thankfully found a position where he’s flourishing, quickly growing into one of the most impactful defensive backs in the SEC.

“When we recruited him out of high school, we didn't really know what [position] we were going to play him,” Steve Sarkisian said after McDonald intercepted a pass and recorded a tackle for loss in last Saturday’s 55-0 win over Sam Houston. McDonald is averaging 7.2 targets per snap, which ranks 14th among SEC safeties who’ve logged at least 20 coverage snaps, according to PFF.

McDonald, whose 115 coverage snaps are the fifth-most by an SEC safety, has cushioned the blow the safety room absorbed when Andrew Mukuba’s eligibility expired at the end of the 2024 season.

“He was playing high school quarterback and, initially, we thought he was going to be a linebacker. When he got here, we moved him to corner, then he found his way back at safety, so his development has been different,” Sarkisian said regarding McDonald’s development. “He's always been very physically gifted, but learning to play the game from that perspective is a little bit different when you've been an offensive type of player. But, to his credit, he's worked on his craft.”

The Longhorns will face tougher challenges when the conference schedule begins next Saturday, when No. 10 Texas hits the road to face Florida (2:30 p.m., ABC). Still, with Michael Taaffe owning PFF's eighth-best coverage grade among SEC safeties (80.2), a top-tier safety tandem will go a long way toward the Longhorns developing into a championship-caliber pass defense, especially if McDonald continues his current upward trajectory.

"Jelani has his physical ability, but now he's really tapping into the mental side of the game," Sarkisian said. "He's communicating at a high level, but his play-making ability is obviously elite. He's a great tackler — probably one of our best tacklers on our team. His ball skills are really good. I just think his confidence and who he's become as a leader, I think, has probably been the most impressive thing. This guy's a real leader on our team — he was a captain tonight — so I'm just really proud of all that he's done to get to this point in his career."