Sam or Quinn

[Jbro52]

I would have liked to see Sam play his last year under Sark but it’s still Quinn hands down 

[Bobbers]

2 hours ago, ThatHornsGuy87 said:

Cool story bud. Remember the bama game before the injury? Or the bama game last year, or the record setting big 12 championship game? How about the Michigan game? Look we get, it you don't like Quinn. But talk to anyone that actually matters, players, coaches and the NFL. It's Quinn. We have to quit acting like the shortcomings of this team fall directly on Quinn. Friday night Sark along with his bone headed play calling, the offensive line didn't help him or the running backs out. 🤘

I love Quinn.  I just typed that neither QB should be run down and they are both great Longhorn QBs.

That didn't stop you from not comprehending and being a dick though.  Read more.

[hookemig]

Not into hypotheticals. Quinn wasn’t perfect, but it’s hard to argue that he didn’t benefit the program in a large way while he was on The Forty.

Ultimately, I am thankful and proud we had both wearing the burnt orange! They too were proud to nth degree to wear Texas on their chests! 

[Deadhead_Horn]

Almost impossible to answer this question. Sam was who he was because he had to be within the offense. Quinn was not asked to do as much because of the talent around him. Not sure Sam was accurate enough to sit in the pocket and throw darts like Quinn did. 

[TexasUnion]

Are we the only fanbase that does this?  Bret Stafford or Todd Dodge, Shea or James Brown, Major or Simms, Quinn or Arch and now the hypothetical Sam or Quinn...and then people pick sides and dig in?  I don't think OP meant it this way, but it always turns into tearing one down.  I love each of them because they are all Longhorns and am proud we had them all.  Hook Em!  🤘

[qaertyisthatdude]

Starting QB or backup QB?

[ThatHornsGuy87]

1 hour ago, Bobbers said:

I love Quinn.  I just typed that neither QB should be run down and they are both great Longhorn QBs.

That didn't stop you from not comprehending and being a dick though.  

Yes ma'am 

[taxsaver]

20 hours ago, thatdude2 said:

Sam had the option to stay and play for Sark, and he chose to leave. 

not true...he played 4 years...no redshirt

[Austalgia]

Love Quinn, but Sam.  

[Austalgia]

14 minutes ago, taxsaver said:

not true...he played 4 years...no redshirt

No, Sam could have stayed.  He debated staying. Wanted a new start. 

Edited January 12 by Austalgia

[thatdude2]

27 minutes ago, taxsaver said:

not true...he played 4 years...no redshirt

Could have used a Covid year

[taxsaver]

1 hour ago, thatdude2 said:

Could have used a Covid year

Are you sure that he could use a Covid year even though he played 4 years, though?

[LILP]

23 hours ago, rgvhorn80 said:

If you could go back and choose a starting  QB for last nights game, with the choice of Sam E or Quinn, who would you choose? Give me Sam all day.

Quinn and it’s not even close. 

[thatdude2]

2 hours ago, taxsaver said:

Are you sure that he could use a Covid year even though he played 4 years, though?

Yea, that was the first senior group that could and some did

[TexasOnTop]

On 1/11/2025 at 2:23 PM, rgvhorn80 said:

If you could go back and choose a starting  QB for last nights game, with the choice of Sam E or Quinn, who would you choose? Give me Sam all day.

Quinn. Stop the nonsense. 

[cmk4pres]

Love Sam, but Quinn. 
 

Easily. 

[TarrantCoHorn]

This thread is garbage

[Rillo HOOK EM]

Sam was great, but give me Quinn. I’m amazed how little he’s appreciated. He’s far from perfect but he’s led us out of the darkness. 

[whereiend]

Sam in 2019 in a Tom Herman offense with one decent receiver:

13 games, 3663 yards, 32 TD 10 Int 8.1 yards/attempt.

 

Quinn in a Sark offense:

14 games, 3472 yards, 31 TD 12 int 7.8 yards/attempt.

 

Where does this "Quinn and it's not close" narrative come from? As passers only it is extremely close. And then Sam is also a weapon with his legs (almost 2k career rushing yards and 33 TDs)... I'm sorry but I think Sam is the clear choice here.

 

That's not disrespecting Quinn, it is respecting how good Sam was.

Edited January 13 by whereiend

[Philip Barber]

Sam would have backed up Quinn.  He probably would have played fullback or H-back.  At Tuscaloosa last year, Sam or Quinn?  At Ann Arbor, Sam or Quinn?  Big 12 championship, Sam or Quinn?  Quinn won.  Sam lost.  Playoffs, Sam or Quinn?  Quinn played in two.  Sam zero.   Sam lost to OU four times.   Sam would never had has at the one yard line.   However, I appreciate Sam and his time here on the forty, but give me Quinn.

[Austalgia]

7 hours ago, TexasUnion said:

Are we the only fanbase that does this?  Bret Stafford or Todd Dodge, Shea or James Brown, Major or Simms, Quinn or Arch and now the hypothetical Sam or Quinn...and then people pick sides and dig in?  I don't think OP meant it this way, but it always turns into tearing one down.  I love each of them because they are all Longhorns and am proud we had them all.  Hook Em!  🤘

Jamal Holloway or Troy Aikman ?

[Burnt Orange Horn]

On 1/11/2025 at 4:23 PM, rgvhorn80 said:

If you could go back and choose a starting  QB for last nights game, with the choice of Sam E or Quinn, who would you choose? Give me Sam all day.

Sam is almost 30 with 4 years in the NFL.  He should be better.

[Clint Baros]

Dont tell me this is gonna be another Applewhite and Simms thing.

 

[Clint Baros]

Just now, Clint Baros said:

Dont tell me this is gonna be another Applewhite and Simms thing.

 

But if i have to answer Quinn

[cmk4pres]

1 hour ago, Rillo HOOK EM said:

Sam was great, but give me Quinn. I’m amazed how little he’s appreciated. He’s far from perfect but he’s led us out of the darkness. 

10000000000000000000%