PK was a good DC but if we're being honest he was best suited for a conference like the Big 12. As good as he was we can't forget that Gary Patterson was needed to come in and help him with Quarters coverages in '22. And for as good as PK was, the fact that he couldn’t coordinate the entire defensive was an issue. We had a championship level team in '23 but the fact that he couldn’t marry the front end to the back end which led to a secondary that got torched by damn near everyone cost that team a national championship.
Not to mention I'm not sure I can recall PK ever trying to make a team "play left-handed". Our weakness in '23 was our secondary because of him not being able to marry the front end to the back but instead of dropping numbers and daring Washington to run into the likes of Sweat/Murphy/Collins/Broughton we sat back and basically let UW do what they wanted to do which was pick our secondary apart. We seemed to fix the issues in '24 after getting Mukuba but this year the same problem.
We watched Florida, Kentucky, Mississippi St, Arkansas and Vanderbilt go up and down the field on his defenses this year with little resistance. We were supposed to have the best pass rushing unit in the entire country with Simmons, Hill, Moore, Burke, etc and we got 0 sacks on Sayin while Indiana sacked him 5 or 6 times. Our supposedly vaunted pass rush was nonexistent for like the first half of the year. How was that even possible with all the studs we had on that side of the ball??
I'm thankful for what PK helped us build to and while I recognize the offense in large parts has been the bigger issue, I can't honestly say the defense hasn't been an issue at times too. I'm excited to see what Muschamp's effect on not just the defense, but the offense is as well.