I’d probably go Jerry Gray if we’re talking best overall résumé in burnt orange. Two-time consensus All-American, elite production, major awards, and College Football Hall of Fame is tough to beat.
Metcalf is the one who makes me pause, though. He was electric in a way that still jumps off the page, and all-purpose impact matters a ton. Golden’s one year was huge, but for a “best No. 2” discussion, I lean toward the guys who stacked it over multiple seasons.