Skip to content

How should Texas deal with Jeremiah Smith in rematch with Ohio State?

AUSTIN, Texas — There was a method to Steve Sarkisian’s madness when the Texas coach embarked on a mission to challenge Malik Muhammad ahead of the team’s second camp scrimmage.

“I purposely went after him with a couple of different things,” Sarkisian said after the scrimmage. “For him to play the way that he played gave me more confidence than I've had, and I have a lot in him. Today was very, very encouraging on that front.”

Muhammad, a veteran cornerback with 18 starts in 30 career games, will begin the 2025 season with arguably the toughest assignment he’ll face as a junior whenever he has to cover Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith. Smith was limited to one reception for three yards on Jan. 10, when the Buckeyes’ 28-14 triumph in the Cotton Bowl ended the Longhorns’ season one game shy of the College Football Playoff National Championship.

“It was a team effort,” Muhammad said earlier in camp about what it took for Texas to hold Smith to his lowest statistical output and his lowest single-game grade from Pro Football Focus during his remarkable true freshman season.

The Longhorns had Smith’s number in Arlington. Still, Sarkisian, who didn’t mention Smith or any other Ohio State wide receivers by name while detailing what Muhammad went through last week, knows coach Ryan Day and offensive coordinator Brian Hartline will be looking to get the 6-foot-3-inch, 223-pound Smith (76 receptions 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns, which established new freshman records for a Buckeye) involved early and often.

The occasions when Muhammad finds himself one-on-one with Smith should be few and far between.

That’s not a knock on the 6-foot, 188-pound Muhammad, who Pro Football Focus touts as the sixth-best returning cornerback in the country. Texas should do whatever it takes to limit the times Smith faces man coverage because he destroyed opponents in those situations last season.

According to PFF, Smith’s 90.6 grade against man coverage was second among FBS wide receivers (minimum of 13 targets), recording 25 receptions for 384 yards and four touchdowns on 32 targets with a near-perfect NFL passer rating when targeted (156.3). Smith also averaged 4.09 yards per route run (sixth in FBS) with an average depth of target of 11.1 yards, indicating that if Will Howard could correctly identify that Smith was facing man coverage, the nation’s No. 1-ranked recruit in 2024 would be turned loose, and Ohio State could hunt chunk-yardage plays (Smith caught 12 passes last season that traveled 20 yards or more down the field, racking up 467 yards and scoring four touchdowns, recording a near-perfect PFF grade of 99.9 when targeted on deep throws).

Julian Sayin, who was named Ohio State’s starting quarterback on Monday, shouldn’t be expected to decipher what Pete Kwiatkowski is throwing at him in his first career start. Nevertheless, it remains to be seen how much Kwiatkowski and Duane Akina alternate between playing man and zone in the opener.

That has more to do with trusting the communication that the secondary has worked to rebuild in the wake of losing Jahdae Barron and Andrew Mukuba than anything else. At the same time, an effective pass rush could make life on the back end much more manageable if the Longhorns can routinely pressure Sayin.

Although Smith was good last season against zone, catching 43 passes for 783 yards and nine touchdowns, shading coverage to his side of the field and devoting more resources to him, in general, is the path of least resistance.

Elevated to the No. 2 wide receiver, with Emeka Egbuka out of eligibility, Carnell Tate was much better against zone last season (a season-long PFF grade of 73.7) than when working against man coverage (59.1). While it’s risky for Texas to let its defensive backs handle Tate, Brandon Inniss and the other Buckeye receiving threats more often in one-on-one situations, Muhammad and the other Longhorn defensive backs should be ready for what they’ll see inside the Horseshoe in 12 days.

User Feedback

Recommended Comments

LovingBuckeye

Members
30 minutes ago, HookemHorns said:

I do think it’ll take time for Arch to become who we all think and hope he will become. 
 

Ditto Sayin.

I’m guessing this is a little lower scoring game. Something like 21-13. Both defenses should have success. Both offenses should be a little sluggish. I’ll admit it worried me that the biggest known for either offense is the elite WRs of Ohio St. Texas doesn’t have a proven strength on offense unless you count Wisner who is good but not elite IMO. 
 

I am expecting Arch to play better than Sayin since he has more college experience. 
 

I am also expecting our defensive line to take another leap this year. 

All very fair points and I think a lot of CFB analysts and national media agree with you.

This is only my opinion, not necessarily shared by other Buckeyes, but I feel like Ohio State’s defense has a much larger advantage against Texas’ offense than Texas’ defense does against Ohio State’s offense.

This is a bit ironic considering my last point, but I would say my biggest fear in this game is what if Sark coaches circles around Matt Patricia? 

LovingBuckeye

Members
17 hours ago, Jarveaux said:

Hopefully Jeremiah meets his match this year!

In fairness to you all, he met his match in the Cotton Bowl :(, fortunately Ohio State was still able to eek out a W

HookemHorns

Supporters
54 minutes ago, LovingBuckeye said:

All very fair points and I think a lot of CFB analysts and national media agree with you.

This is only my opinion, not necessarily shared by other Buckeyes, but I feel like Ohio State’s defense has a much larger advantage against Texas’ offense than Texas’ defense does against Ohio State’s offense.

This is a bit ironic considering my last point, but I would say my biggest fear in this game is what if Sark coaches circles around Matt Patricia? 

What are the strengths/weaknesses of Ohio State’s defense?  I was led to believe they’re replacing their entire dline and they return the most penalized CB in the nation. Outside of Downs I guess there’s not much I fear, but I’m sure I’m missing a whole lot since I don’t follow Ohio St and you’re more confident in Ohio St’s defense than Texas’ defense.

LovingBuckeye

Members
16 minutes ago, HookemHorns said:

What are the strengths/weaknesses of Ohio State’s defense?  I was led to believe they’re replacing their entire dline and they return the most penalized CB in the nation. Outside of Downs I guess there’s not much I fear, but I’m sure I’m missing a whole lot since I don’t follow Ohio St and you’re more confident in Ohio St’s defense than Texas’ defense.

This is game specific and this has to do with the offenses that each team is facing.

I think Ohio State has the superior interior DL to Texas. I think Ohio State has the best defensive backfield in CFB.

There isn’t a WR on Texas that is a threat to Ohio State’s DB’s while Texas’ D has to go up against the #1 WR/TE rooms in the country and one of the best OL’s.

HookemHorns

Supporters
1 hour ago, LovingBuckeye said:

This is game specific and this has to do with the offenses that each team is facing.

I think Ohio State has the superior interior DL to Texas. I think Ohio State has the best defensive backfield in CFB.

There isn’t a WR on Texas that is a threat to Ohio State’s DB’s while Texas’ D has to go up against the #1 WR/TE rooms in the country and one of the best OL’s.

Cant wait to see how it plays out! 
 

Y’all definitely have the #1 WR/TE rooms. Here’s to hoping we find a WR that could be called a threat to your DBs

Here for the Wins

Supporters
1 hour ago, LovingBuckeye said:

This is game specific and this has to do with the offenses that each team is facing.

I think Ohio State has the superior interior DL to Texas. I think Ohio State has the best defensive backfield in CFB.

There isn’t a WR on Texas that is a threat to Ohio State’s DB’s while Texas’ D has to go up against the #1 WR/TE rooms in the country and one of the best OL’s.

Exactly why is your Oline one of the best?

Wingo likely has the best size/speed combo of any WR your guys have seen this year or last. The wonderful C Tate has 5 career TDs, 2 versus Northwestern.  He has 3 games with 6 or more catches at approximately 10 yards per catch there.  His numbers will undoubtedly go up, but he’s yet to produce big plays.  He versus Moore is a virtual push.

I am not sure Klare is markedly different than Endries.

Seems as though you are undervaluing the Wngo/Moore/Endries group.  

It will come down to who wins more often upfront.  I believe you will see a different level of pass rush from us this year than you did last.  You were not dominant in the run games against our D.  I don’t see that differently this year.  It certainly could come down to who breaks some unexpected big plays.

alincoln

Members

Texas is going to absolutely destroy Ohio State on both sides of the LOS.  Sayin will be extremely fortunate to leave this game under his own power. I will be very surprised if Kleinholz isn’t the QB in the second half.  Buckeye running game is going to be a massive weakness all season.  Everyone is going to bracket Smith and win against the run while the undersized and beat up Sayin struggles to stay in games.  Buckeye DL is the weakest it has been in living memory,  if camp reports suggest they are improving then the Buckeye OL is even worse than we thought.  Michigan 2024 redux. 

LovingBuckeye

Members
21 minutes ago, Here for the Wins said:

Exactly why is your Oline one of the best?

Wingo likely has the best size/speed combo of any WR your guys have seen this year or last. The wonderful C Tate has 5 career TDs, 2 versus Northwestern.  He has 3 games with 6 or more catches at approximately 10 yards per catch there.  His numbers will undoubtedly go up, but he’s yet to produce big plays.  He versus Moore is a virtual push.

I am not sure Klare is markedly different than Endries.

Seems as though you are undervaluing the Wngo/Moore/Endries group.  

It will come down to who wins more often upfront.  I believe you will see a different level of pass rush from us this year than you did last.  You were not dominant in the run games against our D.  I don’t see that differently this year.  It certainly could come down to who breaks some unexpected big plays.

Hey Here for the Wins, thank you for you comment and I’ll give my opinions on each one of your comments

1. I believe Ohio State will have one of the best offensive lines in the country because they return all 3 of their IOL starters from last season as well as their top two backups. Aside from that, the tackles have reportedly played very well in fall camp. Also, Ohio State has invested heavily in the OL coaching staff this off season, which I believe is the largest OL staff in CFB.

2. Ohio State’s CB’s and safeties go up against Ohio State’s wide receivers every day in practice. They won’t face better receivers than what they see on the daily. Carnell Tate was highly sought after by Brian Hartline, so that tells me all I need to know about Tate.

3. As for the TE room, it’s not just Max Klare. That room goes 4 deep with legitimate P4 starters, but I have seen Max Klare on several first round mock drafts, I haven’t seen Endries on any mock drafts.

4. I could be undervaluing the wide receivers but how would I know when they’ve never done it before?

5. I’m very confident in Ohio State’s OL against Texas’ DL. Especially because I’m not expecting UT’s DT’s to be dominant and the IOL is Ohio State’s strength.

LovingBuckeye

Members
1 minute ago, alincoln said:

Texas is going to absolutely destroy Ohio State on both sides of the LOS.  Sayin will be extremely fortunate to leave this game under his own power. I will be very surprised if Kleinholz isn’t the QB in the second half.  Buckeye running game is going to be a massive weakness all season.  Everyone is going to bracket Smith and win against the run while the undersized and beat up Sayin struggles to stay in games.  Buckeye DL is the weakest it has been in living memory,  if camp reports suggest they are improving then the Buckeye OL is even worse than we thought.  Michigan 2024 redux. 

None of that is accurate lol

alincoln

Members

OSU’s only advantage In this game is at WR1 and FS.  Texas is better at every other position on the field.  Ohio State’s DL would be in the bottom quartile of the SEC and the OL would be bottom half.  Sayin is a dead man walking. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Add a comment...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.