Skip to content

Snap Judgments: No. 1 Texas earned a 27-24 loss to Oklahoma in the Red River Shootout

Texas earned Saturday’s 27-24 walk-off loss to Oklahoma in the Red River Shootout.

The Sooners beat the Longhorns in the trenches in the second half, out-rushing Texas (4-1, 1-1 SEC) by 30 yards (82-52) and forcing two turnovers. Arch Manning, not John Mateer, made catastrophic mistakes, with two interceptions that led to 10 points for Oklahoma (3-2, 1-1), including Tate Sandell’s game-winning 47-yard field goal.

The inexplicable loss isn’t solely on Manning’s shoulders.  The Longhorns couldn’t get a push in the running game when it mattered, Steve Sarkisian’s play-calling was as questionable as ever and Will Muschamp’s defense faltered down the stretch (although the defense was by far the better of the three phases on Saturday).

Texas is an undisciplined team that can’t run the football when it needs to, is inexplicably sloppy on special teams and failed to put its foot on the gas with a double-digit lead for the second consecutive game.

***

Oklahoma had a distinct path to victory. The action at the Cotton Bowl unfolded in the Sooners’ favor.

The Longhorns lost the turnover battle, 2-0.

Oklahoma improved to 16-2 under Brent Venables when scoring a non-offensive touchdown.

Mateer (18-for-26 for 155 yards) avoided making the backbreaking mistakes that plagued him through the Sooners’ first four games.

Oklahoma won the line-of-scrimmage battle when it mattered and seized the momentum when Texas left the door open for a potential comeback. We’ve seen Red River upsets unfold similarly in the past, which is why the Sooners taking the Golden Hat back to Norman isn’t a surprise, given how things unfolded in Dallas.

***

Even though Oklahoma’s defense lived up to its billing, seven three-and-outs, a pick-six and a missed field goal would’ve been more than enough to question where Sarkisian’s offense is going.

Then there was the last drive of the game.

The four-play drive that ended with Courtland Guillory’s interception of Manning felt like a microcosm of what’s wrong with the Longhorns on a side of the ball that’s putting out a product on par with last season's lackluster showing. Whether it’s a lack of hot routes or built-in advantage throws against blitzes, Manning’s inability or unwillingness to get the offense out of bad plays or questionable football IQ in a two-minute situation, Texas is too disjointed to take advantage of the talent Sarkisian’s organization acquired in the offseason.

Inconsistency is the only thing consistent about the Longhorn offense. The boom-or-bust nature of Sarkisian’s offense has a low ceiling for a team that can’t rely on the kicking game to do anything other than put the defense on short fields or give up points.

***

While the season isn’t over, the loss means that Sarkisian has no choice but to look in the mirror and see what changes must be made to improve the product.

Texas’ offensive identity, when push comes to shove, is still to snap the ball to Manning and hope something good happens. When it works, it’s great. When it doesn’t work, you get the outcome you got on Saturday.

Sarkisian can figure out what’s working and hammer those concepts so that the Longhorns can lean on a few things. Or he can keep dialing things up that, while they might look cool enough on tape to put on the call sheet, aren’t doing anything other than getting the offense behind the chains.

***

The opening kickoff going out of bounds was a bad omen.

I don’t like calling for a coach’s job. Still, for Jeff Banks’ unit to answer a forgettable showing against Tennessee with a performance that was worse against the Sooners is troubling, to say the least.

***

There aren’t enough adjectives to describe the nature of Saturday’s loss.

After doing what it needed to do to keep their College Football Playoff fate out of the selection committee’s hands through the first four games, Texas now has little to no margin for error. Unless Sarkisian's long-awaited desire for his club to play consistent complementary football is realized, the loss to Oklahoma won't be the last that the Longhorns suffer before the end of the regular season.

Texas did enough right to win the Ohio State and Tennessee games. It didn't do enough right to win on Saturday, with a lot of mistakes and misfires looking all too familiar.

The Longhorns have played with fire more than once this year. They finally got burned.

User Feedback

Recommended Comments

Califashorn75

Supporters

I am severely disappointed but we are likely to run off five wins in a row. The nature of this team is that it's Jeckell and Hyde. Simmons didn't do much the second half. But he was a monster for one quarter. Our running game is sporadic at best. Ricky is not coming in to run. Arch tantalizes but then throws really bad interceptions.  We have better players than most so we should win a few more games. But do I think we can win a Natty? Nope. 

9 minutes ago, Jeff Howe said:

Arch is part of the problem, but he's not THE problem.

Sark shares a lot of the blame. So does the offensive line.

And credit to Oklahoma. They punched Texas in the mouth in the second half and the Longhorns didn't respond.

Still another half of the season, but what if Arch wants to come back for another year? Say yes or move on to Lacey and Bell?

HookedOnTF

Supporters
5 minutes ago, thatdude2 said:

Thank you for your response. Cam Coleman had a good game. Our two offensive freshman had some big moments today. The team needed this loss, and Arch needed this loss. All will be well. It just sucks losing, and to me as a fan I hate losing to OU more than anybody. Now being #1 is off our back. All 3 units had a role in the loss. Now we can turn it loose. 

Love it and Hook Em but I'm not sure we have 'it' to turn loose.

nineliveslost

Supporters
Just now, Arch2025 said:

Again.. you know as well as I do ..Sark ain’t hiring an OC…  Quin actually played better than Arch…   So if Sark leaves …don’t expect UT to hire the right guy …history has proven the disaster hires of the last 20 yrs.  I’ll settle for a portal QB.  
 

hope Arch never leaves .

I always wonder this. How does Ohio State always hire great coaches ? 

SuperDave0805

Supporters
6 minutes ago, Arch2025 said:

Spin what u want.  Different QB..Different result.  Period.  Stop blaming Sark for getting UT out of laughing stock 10+ yrs of misery… then blaming him for play calling.  Guys are open.  Period.  He can’t throw it.  There are sevaeral QBs that elevate when the game begins.  Arch panics every other series.  Time to accept a waste of 40 mill roster cause your QB is mid…..

hope he goes pro for UTs sake

Then Sark should do what is best for the team and give a Lacy a chance if the offense looks putrid against Florida 

NTX_Horn

Members
Just now, nineliveslost said:

I actually see 8-4 a possibility. 9 and 3 would be more likely and miss the playoffs. OU will be our Florida this year. 

8-4 would make some booster heads roll, that’s for sure.  

  • Moderators
Just now, Randy Fistfighter said:

Still another half of the season, but what if Arch wants to come back for another year? Say yes or move on to Lacey and Bell?

I just don't think Arch is a good fit for what Sark wants to do on offense.

SuperDave0805

Supporters
1 minute ago, Randy Fistfighter said:

Still another half of the season, but what if Arch wants to come back for another year? Say yes or move on to Lacey and Bell?

Give him Auburns number and wish him well 

HookedOnTF

Supporters
1 minute ago, Randy Fistfighter said:

Still another half of the season, but what if Arch wants to come back for another year? Say yes or move on to Lacey and Bell?

Do you know if KJ and Bell can execute Sark's playbook?

HookedOnTF

Supporters
3 minutes ago, nineliveslost said:

I always wonder this. How does Ohio State always hire great coaches ? 

Day is not a great coach. He inherited a great program, and his success is only coming from hiring NFL OC & DC

And before urban, they really only had the one success under tressle, and a lot of mediocre before that they just have never really wandered in the desert

Jamieson

Supporters

I said last time sark needs to stay in ten personnel to get manning in a rhythm. More slants quick outs and comeback routes.  It’s mostly sarks fault he is trying to adapt the players to the play calls instead of the other way around.  Arch needs to man up and ask his uncles for advice he’s constantly staring down receivers not moving the defense with his eyes.  This offense has to many stars for this offense to be anemic.  Advice to Sark admit your faults and take a look in the mirror like Ryan Day did and just be the head coach and you could be rewarded with a national championship for your sacrifice.  Team first everything else doesn’t matter.

Just now, HookedOnTF said:

Do you know if KJ and Bell can execute Sark's playbook?

I don't, which is why I'm asking. And as Jeff previously quoted, maybe they fit Sarks offense better.

nineliveslost

Supporters
Just now, HookedOnTF said:

Do you know if KJ and Bell can execute Sark's playbook?

Sark's playbook is the problem. He smashes square pegs into round holes. He doesnt adjust to his talent he demands his talent adjust to his playbook. 

nineliveslost

Supporters
Just now, HookedOnTF said:

Day is not a great coach. He inherited a great program, and his success is only coming from hiring NFL OC & DC

I wish Sark was not a great coach with a ring and hired NFL OC & DC 

rynslmns

Supporters

When do we get to see what Lacey or Bell has?

HookedOnTF

Supporters
4 minutes ago, SuperDave0805 said:

Then Sark should do what is best for the team and give a Lacy a chance if the offense looks putrid against Florida 

If k j is the clear number one in practice he might have to, but what happens if the same reason he didnt put Arch on for Quinn is what this room looks like with the playbook?

NTX_Horn

Members
4 minutes ago, Jeff Howe said:

I just don't think Arch is a good fit for what Sark wants to do on offense.

He recruited him.  Is the QB whisperer bad at evals or development?  

Texasborn91

Supporters
5 minutes ago, Jeff Howe said:

I just don't think Arch is a good fit for what Sark wants to do on offense.

Who is? He’s taken 2 1.000 rated #1 ranked 5 stars and wasted them. 

HookedOnTF

Supporters
2 minutes ago, rynslmns said:

When do we get to see what Lacey or Bell has?

In the three non conference games and the spring game. Oh, right.

Big Tex

Supporters
3 minutes ago, Jeff Howe said:

I just don't think Arch is a good fit for what Sark wants to do on offense.

What exactly is Sark trying to do on offense? Ewers not a good fit. Arch not a good fit. Based upon what I know, KJ isn't a good fit either. If the offense requires Tom Brady to work we might be waiting forever. 

tedsel76

Supporters

I just don’t understand how in less than a month we’ve gone from “winners win baby, you gotta go for it” to whatever the hell that was on 4th & 2. That’s each of the last 2 losses in this game where Sark has been asked if he is man or mouse and he has picked mouse twice. Just don’t get why he turns conservative in this spot

pinkman_90

Supporters
7 minutes ago, Jeff Howe said:

I just don't think Arch is a good fit for what Sark wants to do on offense.

Does Sark know what he wants to do on offense?

Alex Butler

Supporters
9 minutes ago, Califashorn75 said:

I am severely disappointed but we are likely to run off five wins in a row. The nature of this team is that it's Jeckell and Hyde. Simmons didn't do much the second half. But he was a monster for one quarter. Our running game is sporadic at best. Ricky is not coming in to run. Arch tantalizes but then throws really bad interceptions.  We have better players than most so we should win a few more games. But do I think we can win a Natty? Nope. 

They doubled him and held like crazy all over. The defense didn’t lose that one at all. He had two sacks. We gave them 14 points directly from turnovers/special teams and another 3 off of a turnover. Plus the refs gave them their only offensive td with that trash DPI and roughing the passer call. @Jeff Howe is spot on that loss was earned by Texas. 

Clifton

Supporters

This IMO is the worst loss since Sark took over. I know Florida was bad last year, but you had a double digit lead. 
 

Arch made mistakes, but Sark week in and week out makes odd choices given situations. 
 

The blocked punt was pseudo because he was so aggressive down in his own 10. 
 

An embarrassing loss. 

pinkman_90

Supporters
1 minute ago, Clifton said:

This IMO is the worst loss since Sark took over. I know Florida was bad last year, but you had a double digit lead. 
 

Arch made mistakes, but Sark week in and week out makes odd choices given situations. 
 

The blocked punt was pseudo because he was so aggressive down in his own 10. 
 

An embarrassing loss. 

The game changed when Venables put out his punter to do a little gimmick that was gonna end in a pooch punt.  Sark panicked and called TO.  Oklahoma kicks a field goal.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Add a comment...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.