Skip to content

Snap Judgments: No. 1 Texas earned a 27-24 loss to Oklahoma in the Red River Shootout

Texas earned Saturday’s 27-24 walk-off loss to Oklahoma in the Red River Shootout.

The Sooners beat the Longhorns in the trenches in the second half, out-rushing Texas (4-1, 1-1 SEC) by 30 yards (82-52) and forcing two turnovers. Arch Manning, not John Mateer, made catastrophic mistakes, with two interceptions that led to 10 points for Oklahoma (3-2, 1-1), including Tate Sandell’s game-winning 47-yard field goal.

The inexplicable loss isn’t solely on Manning’s shoulders.  The Longhorns couldn’t get a push in the running game when it mattered, Steve Sarkisian’s play-calling was as questionable as ever and Will Muschamp’s defense faltered down the stretch (although the defense was by far the better of the three phases on Saturday).

Texas is an undisciplined team that can’t run the football when it needs to, is inexplicably sloppy on special teams and failed to put its foot on the gas with a double-digit lead for the second consecutive game.

***

Oklahoma had a distinct path to victory. The action at the Cotton Bowl unfolded in the Sooners’ favor.

The Longhorns lost the turnover battle, 2-0.

Oklahoma improved to 16-2 under Brent Venables when scoring a non-offensive touchdown.

Mateer (18-for-26 for 155 yards) avoided making the backbreaking mistakes that plagued him through the Sooners’ first four games.

Oklahoma won the line-of-scrimmage battle when it mattered and seized the momentum when Texas left the door open for a potential comeback. We’ve seen Red River upsets unfold similarly in the past, which is why the Sooners taking the Golden Hat back to Norman isn’t a surprise, given how things unfolded in Dallas.

***

Even though Oklahoma’s defense lived up to its billing, seven three-and-outs, a pick-six and a missed field goal would’ve been more than enough to question where Sarkisian’s offense is going.

Then there was the last drive of the game.

The four-play drive that ended with Courtland Guillory’s interception of Manning felt like a microcosm of what’s wrong with the Longhorns on a side of the ball that’s putting out a product on par with last season's lackluster showing. Whether it’s a lack of hot routes or built-in advantage throws against blitzes, Manning’s inability or unwillingness to get the offense out of bad plays or questionable football IQ in a two-minute situation, Texas is too disjointed to take advantage of the talent Sarkisian’s organization acquired in the offseason.

Inconsistency is the only thing consistent about the Longhorn offense. The boom-or-bust nature of Sarkisian’s offense has a low ceiling for a team that can’t rely on the kicking game to do anything other than put the defense on short fields or give up points.

***

While the season isn’t over, the loss means that Sarkisian has no choice but to look in the mirror and see what changes must be made to improve the product.

Texas’ offensive identity, when push comes to shove, is still to snap the ball to Manning and hope something good happens. When it works, it’s great. When it doesn’t work, you get the outcome you got on Saturday.

Sarkisian can figure out what’s working and hammer those concepts so that the Longhorns can lean on a few things. Or he can keep dialing things up that, while they might look cool enough on tape to put on the call sheet, aren’t doing anything other than getting the offense behind the chains.

***

The opening kickoff going out of bounds was a bad omen.

I don’t like calling for a coach’s job. Still, for Jeff Banks’ unit to answer a forgettable showing against Tennessee with a performance that was worse against the Sooners is troubling, to say the least.

***

There aren’t enough adjectives to describe the nature of Saturday’s loss.

After doing what it needed to do to keep their College Football Playoff fate out of the selection committee’s hands through the first four games, Texas now has little to no margin for error. Unless Sarkisian's long-awaited desire for his club to play consistent complementary football is realized, the loss to Oklahoma won't be the last that the Longhorns suffer before the end of the regular season.

Texas did enough right to win the Ohio State and Tennessee games. It didn't do enough right to win on Saturday, with a lot of mistakes and misfires looking all too familiar.

The Longhorns have played with fire more than once this year. They finally got burned.

User Feedback

Recommended Comments

AusMOJO

Members

This was about as tough a loss as I can remember. Because OU was inferior, like not even in our league. Yet we let them hang around instead of going for the throat. Something Sark lacks. You gifted them points and still they hung around.

I don't put any of this on the D, they dominated this game and basically gift wrapped a Texas win. Only for the O and special teams to pee all over it. 

There was several penalties on D that sucked but some of them were so egregious I just can't with it. The refs seemed determined to call anything on that drive to keep OU in the game.

This has been a problem all year but no one wanted to hear it because "well a win is a win" and now it's a loss, to your rival who absolute sucks. 

AusMOJO

Members
4 hours ago, HookemChappy said:

You think PKs defense would have allowed us to win OSU and Tenn game. Defense is not the problem go back and watch the short field the scored on

PK against Ohio State gave up 21 in the playoff game in '24, where the offense fumbled the game away with a chance to tie it. 

Last year on the road, held them to 14 points (7 if Guillbeau turned his head and made a play on the ball).

PK certainly had his issues, I don't deny that. But he 100% got scapegoated by Sark. As it turns out, Sark was full of it. 

AusMOJO

Members

One thing I'm surprised about is the lack of turnovers by Muschamp's D. They would've had a couple today if not for some untimely errors. Considering how turnover prone Mateer was. 

Also thought they would sack him more with how bad their OL is. 

AusMOJO

Members
4 hours ago, Jeff Howe said:

This is also Texas' third consecutive loss coming out of a bye week. The Florida and Georgia losses last season came after byes.

What the heck is happening on the Forty Acres during the bye week?

Apparently take it easy and do nothing. Because they look like they just got off vacation after every bye week. 

TexasFight12

Supporters

After sleeping on it, the season isn’t over. In fact, Texas can still lose one more game and make the Playoffs. 
 

Sark has to get Arch’s legs more involved. That’s the key to success 🤘

kren

Supporters

I actually thought Arch saw the field decently (from my seat). Made some good throws. The pick 6 was horribly inaccurate to a wide open Cam Coleman. The second INT I got nothing for ya though. I’m much more frustrated now about the penalties and special teams pissing away these games

  • Moderators

I legitimately don’t understand why Texas defense is coming up in the OU loss discussion. 

Texas defense is the only phase that is playing/showing championship caliber performance. 

It’s damn hard to lose a game when a defense holds an opponent to 238 yards and 2-13 on third downs. 

Texas offense and special teams are the reason there is a loss in the column. Period. 

I’m still waiting on somebody to show me a successful QB sark put in the league that amounted to anything in the league. The stats don’t lie. From 2021-2026, the offense has gotten statistically worse. Sark ruined Quinn and he has absolutely FAILED to develop arch. Arch will not be going to the league after this season, but I’m not sure he will be at Texas next season either. Sark has already hit his ceiling. You can’t convince me otherwise. And please spare me the “two final fours” to defend him when one of those playoff appearances was given to Texas bc Florida st got hosed.

13 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said:

I legitimately don’t understand why Texas defense is coming up in the OU loss discussion. 

Texas defense is the only phase that is playing/showing championship caliber performance. 

It’s damn hard to lose a game when a defense holds an opponent to 238 yards and 2-13 on third downs. 

Texas offense and special teams are the reason there is a loss in the column. Period. 

The wrong coach got fired last season. 

AusMOJO

Members
3 minutes ago, Texas fan in Georgia said:

The wrong coach got fired last season. 

Nah, it was all PK's fault. Sark had to babysit him....lol. 

AusMOJO

Members
17 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said:

I legitimately don’t understand why Texas defense is coming up in the OU loss discussion. 

Texas defense is the only phase that is playing/showing championship caliber performance. 

It’s damn hard to lose a game when a defense holds an opponent to 238 yards and 2-13 on third downs. 

Texas offense and special teams are the reason there is a loss in the column. Period. 

If not for the O and special teams this defense might've legit given up 3-6 points total. If not for the big 40 yard run OU would've had under 200 total yards. 

I think the D still has things to improve but they've once again carried this team and are 100% not the reason we lost. 

texcoyote15

Supporters

Do you all think Sark can get this offense playing at a high enough level to make a run this year?  Fix special teams this year?  Are what we’ve seen is it?  What percentage do you give that he can do it?

1 minute ago, texcoyote15 said:

Do you all think Sark can get this offense playing at a high enough level to make a run this year?  Fix special teams this year?  Are what we’ve seen is it?  What percentage do you give that he can do it?

0%. 

HornFanatic

Supporters
11 hours ago, Arch2025 said:

Spin what u want.  Different QB..Different result.  Period.  Stop blaming Sark for getting UT out of laughing stock 10+ yrs of misery… then blaming him for play calling.  Guys are open.  Period.  He can’t throw it.  There are sevaeral QBs that elevate when the game begins.  Arch panics every other series.  Time to accept a waste of 40 mill roster cause your QB is mid…..

hope he goes pro for UTs sake

I completely agree that Sark has brought us out of the 10 years of misery. However, there is a paralysis by analysis happening at the QB position. Sark adjusted to the quick passing game with Quinn and started to limit the deep looks. 
How many times has Arch had over 3 seconds to throw and just bounces patting the ball?? It’s obvious Manning has been told not to run as much going forward and that has been practiced. He is coached to go through reads. Has anyone ever thought the people we see open is third or fourth in his read progression??
Doing the same thing over and over expecting different results is the definition of insanity. It’s time for Sark to adjust his play calls and do what his players excel at. 
Leading the SEC in three and outs is unacceptable with the money spent on this offense. 
Allowing a touchdown on special teams in both conference games is unacceptable. Everyone said if the offense and special teams don’t improve we will lose. Now we have lost to one of the worst teams in the SEC. 
The offense has averaged less points per game each year the last 4 years. Let that sink in. Sark said it was due helping PK on defense. Well, PK is gone. Whatever he did for Arch to actually show improvement the last half of 2025 Sark needs to go to it immediately 

Jim Douglas

Supporters
11 hours ago, HookemChappy said:

Arch is the majority of the problem. 

Sark not developing arch is the whole problem

Jim Douglas

Supporters
8 hours ago, UT_Ro said:

Like I said it's his fault a player didn't block the dude that ran right past him & blocked the punt? 

Are parents not responsible for their children’s actions at some point?

in sec country

Supporters
12 hours ago, Jeff Howe said:

I don't like calling for a coach's job, but coaches have been fired for less than the product Jeff Banks has put on the field the last two games.

Well written opinion.  Sark repeatedly talks about the standard. Why isn't Jeff Banks held to the standard? Why is Sark's play calling not held to the standard?

  • Moderators
1 hour ago, texcoyote15 said:

Do you all think Sark can get this offense playing at a high enough level to make a run this year?  Fix special teams this year?  Are what we’ve seen is it?  What percentage do you give that he can do it?

Yes, Sark can get the offense to a level of play that, when paired with the caliber of defense Texas has, can allow you to go on a run.

Whether he'll do those things is a different matter.

Jermaine Bishop and Derrek Cooper need more touches.

He's either got to use Arch's legs as a weapon and/or put things on the call sheet that can help Arch play from the pocket.

He's got to figure out the run game concepts that work or that his personnel can execute and stick to those.

It can happen. I'm just not confident that it will, because we've basically seen the same offense since the second quarter of the UTSA game.

Special teams can be fixed either through scheme changes or personnel. Again, it looked worse after the bye week, so I'm not confident that they'll get it right in the kicking game.

 

HookemChappy

Supporters
54 minutes ago, Jim Douglas said:

Sark not developing arch is the whole problem

You are assuming that anyone could have developed arch art fundamentally has a processing problem. I don’t know if any coach can actually solve that just because he has the Manning name doesn’t mean he’s gonna be an NFL star

1 minute ago, HookemChappy said:

You are assuming that anyone could have developed arch art fundamentally has a processing problem. I don’t know if any coach can actually solve that just because he has the Manning name doesn’t mean he’s gonna be an NFL star

People also forget that he’s not the son of a Manning QB. His dad was a reciever. Maybe he’s playing the wrong position. 

Jim Douglas

Supporters
11 minutes ago, HookemChappy said:

You are assuming that anyone could have developed arch art fundamentally has a processing problem. I don’t know if any coach can actually solve that just because he has the Manning name doesn’t mean he’s gonna be an NFL star

I would agree with you if Quinn didn’t also regress in this offense. And if arch was allowed to use his legs like he was last year. 

UT_Ro

Supporters
3 hours ago, Jim Douglas said:

Are parents not responsible for their children’s actions at some point?

Parents are responsible. That's a whole other discussion. The player ran in between 2 guys it's pretty obvious your suppose to block said guy & I'm pretty sure banks tells them to block not let them run through

Thorn007

Members

Monkey banks needs gone. Now

mmdaytontexas

Supporters
12 hours ago, AusMOJO said:

PK against Ohio State gave up 21 in the playoff game in '24, where the offense fumbled the game away with a chance to tie it. 

Last year on the road, held them to 14 points (7 if Guillbeau turned his head and made a play on the ball).

PK certainly had his issues, I don't deny that. But he 100% got scapegoated by Sark. As it turns out, Sark was full of it. 

💯💯💯💯

PK was scapegoated. Texas fans are so damn gullible. We bought the Muschamp will make me better as an OC and HC con job. Sark doesn't have a clue what is wrong. He doesn't hold himself or his coaches responsible for anything outside of recruiting failures.

AusMOJO

Members
6 hours ago, mmdaytontexas said:

💯💯💯💯

PK was scapegoated. Texas fans are so damn gullible. We bought the Muschamp will make me better as an OC and HC con job. Sark doesn't have a clue what is wrong. He doesn't hold himself or his coaches responsible for anything outside of recruiting failures.

Turns out we just traded one great DC for another great DC and the offense actually looks worse. I'm honestly baffled even to what the issue is. They've played maybe a couple of quarters of good offensive football through 4 games now. Excluding the Texas State game because they seemed to click there but it's Texas State. 

I'm just lost for word son how we spent all this money on O to "improve" it and somehow it looks objectively worse than last year. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Add a comment...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.