Skip to content

Portal Ratings vs. Expectations

Featured Replies

Curious thoughts on an overall pretty good portal haul with some flaws:

My portal ratings relative to expectations

Offense

• WR Cam Coleman – F

• WR Sterling Berkhalter – Depth

• RB Raleek Brown – A

• RB Hollywood Smothers – Incomplete

• QB MJ Morris – Depth

• TE Michael Masunas – D

• OT Melvin Siani – C

• OT Dylan Sikorski – B+

• OT Jonte Newman – Depth

• OL Laurence Seymore – Depth

Defense

• LB Rasheem Biles – A+

• LB Justin Cryer – A+

• LB Markus Boswell – Depth

• DL Ian Geffrard – A

• DT Zion Williams – Depth

• CB Bo Mascoe – A+

Special Teams

• K Gianni Spetic – A

• P Mac Chiumento – C-

• LS Trey Dubuc – A because I haven’t heard his name

  • Author

Template for the group

Offense

• WR Cam Coleman

• WR Sterling Berkhalter

• RB Raleek Brown

• RB Hollywood Smothers

• QB MJ Morris

• TE Michael Masunas

• OT Melvin Siani

• OT Dylan Sikorski

• OT Jonte Newman

• OL Laurence Seymore

Defense

• LB Rasheem Biles

• LB Justin Cryer

• LB Markus Boswell

• DL Ian Geffrard

• DT Zion Williams

• CB Bo Mascoe

Special Teams

• K Gianni Spetic

• P Mac Chiumento

• LS Trey Dubuc

Edited by BijanIsKing

I’m in agreement with your list overall. Maybe a little higher on Masunas since he was brought here just to be a blocker. I’d give him a B. Spetic is an A+ for me. I had some concerns given his previous stats and he’s excelled.

Just now, Quinncent McManning, Jr. said:

Gefridge is an a plus. Can’t find anyone else in the country that does what he does.

There were Arky fans saying he’s soft against the run when he portaled😂. They were referring to one single run last season that he had a bad rep on I forgot which game.

2 minutes ago, hookem1014 said:

There were Arky fans saying he’s soft against the run when he portaled😂. They were referring to one single run last season that he had a bad rep on I forgot which game.

Memphis back up quarterback dragged him

I’m not sure I’m as high on Mascoe as you are. He’s very good, but not A+ (which would mean he is effectively at the same level of performance as Biles). Spetic gets an A+ from me because he has been absolutely automatic, and I had big doubts about him before the season. Cryer has been a huge surprise. FSU fans made it sound like he couldn’t tie his own shoes, but he’s been really damn good.

pretty good, but way to hard on Coleman. dude's been hurt half the season. He's had some good grabs too, TDs...
he hasn't been as advertised, but even when he's worse, he's a distraction to the D. F is pretty harsh imo. C or Incomplete I think.

Masunas a bit higher too. Hasn't been a home run by any stretch, but serviceable. I'd go more C+/B- on him.

Pretty good hit rate I think when you look at it across the board and in comp to other programs, except on OL... 😔

🤘

  • Author
1 minute ago, Paul Jespersen said:

pretty good, but way to hard on Coleman. dude's been hurt half the season. He's had some good grabs too, TDs...
he hasn't been as advertised, but even when he's worse, he's a distraction to the D. F is pretty harsh imo. C or Incomplete I think.

Masunas a bit higher too. Hasn't been a home run by any stretch, but serviceable. I'd go more C+/B- on him.

Pretty good hit rate I think when you look at it across the board and in comp to other programs, except on OL... 😔

🤘

Agree I was too harsh on Masunas, probably a bit too harsh on Coleman too given the injuries. However relative to expectations even when he was healthy, I find it hard to go above a D unfortunately.

31 minutes ago, BijanIsKing said:

Curious thoughts on an overall pretty good portal haul with some flaws:

My portal ratings relative to expectations

Offense

• WR Cam Coleman – F

• WR Sterling Berkhalter – Depth

• RB Raleek Brown – A

• RB Hollywood Smothers – Incomplete

• QB MJ Morris – Depth

• TE Michael Masunas – D

• OT Melvin Siani – C

• OT Dylan Sikorski – B+

• OT Jonte Newman – Depth

• OL Laurence Seymore – Depth

Defense

• LB Rasheem Biles – A+

• LB Justin Cryer – A+

• LB Markus Boswell – Depth

• DL Ian Geffrard – A

• DT Zion Williams – Depth

• CB Bo Mascoe – A+

Special Teams

• K Gianni Spetic – A

• P Mac Chiumento – C-

• LS Trey Dubuc – A because I haven’t heard his name

No wonder you are not in a professional position in college athletics!!! 🤦🏼

🤘🏻🤘🏼🤘🤘🏽🤘🏾🤘🏿

I’d go a c- on Coleman because he does have 8 td catches and some flash plays. Overall not as advertised. Masunas a solid B. He’s actually caught I think every ball thrown his way.

Would be curious for previous years as well - I believe usually by the end of the season, the key contributors aren't the same names as the ones expected during the off season. Example when it was Golden at the end of the year and the expectation was Bond.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.