Moderators Gerry Hamilton Posted 2 hours ago Moderators Posted 2 hours ago Ranking the SEC QB's: OTF community Wanted to see how everyone in the OTF community would rank the SEC QB's post portal and coaching changes... Arch Manning, Texas *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Sam Leavitt, LSU Gunnar Stockton, Georgia John Mateer, Oklahoma LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky Austin Simmons, Missouri George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtin, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama 4 Quote
Joe Zura Posted 2 hours ago Posted 2 hours ago (edited) Gerry you and I are so different on the fraud ASU QB. What are you seeing that I am not on him. Here is what I think about him. He quit on his team, watched some games and he has a piss poor attitude on the field when things are not going good. Would love your opinion dad lol. Edited 1 hour ago by Joe Zura 3 3 Quote
Moderators Gerry Hamilton Posted 1 hour ago Author Moderators Posted 1 hour ago 8 minutes ago, Joe Zura said: Gerry you and I are so different on the fraud ASU QB. What are you seeing that I am not on him. Here is what I think about him. He quit on his team, watched some games and he has a piss poor attitude on the field when things are not going good. Would love your opinion dad lol. 11 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said: Ranking the SEC QB's: OTF community Wanted to see how everyone in the OTF community would rank the SEC QB's post portal and coaching changes... Arch Manning, Texas *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Sam Leavitt, LSU Gunnar Stockton, Georgia John Mateer, Oklahoma LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky Austin Simmons, Missouri George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtin, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama BTW, not my ranking. Just the list of projected starting QB's in the SEC 2 Quote
Joe Zura Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago 1 minute ago, Gerry Hamilton said: BTW, not my ranking. Just the list of projected starting QB's in the SEC Na I saw the video you and CJ posted the other day mister you have to answer for your crimes lol 1 2 Quote
Moderators Gerry Hamilton Posted 1 hour ago Author Moderators Posted 1 hour ago 9 minutes ago, Joe Zura said: Gerry you and I are so different on the fraud ASU QB. What are you seeing that I am not on him. Here is what I think about him. He quit on his team, watched some games and he has a piss poor attitude on the field when things are not going good. Would love your opinion dad lol. I'm not sure having a foot injury that required surgery is quitting on a team. He actually tried to play with a foot issue, and it ended up making it worse. We'll see how it finishes for him in 2026, but he's playing for Lane Kiffin with his talent and playmaking ... I'm betting he has a very good season. His biggest issue for me is his brother trying to get in agent business, and what that creates in a negative way. He needs to block out that noise, and go focus solely on ball. 3 Quote
TexasMDcoach Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago I have a hard time ranking John Mateer. He looked good until his injury and then really never got it together after that. How much was mental versus having a horrible offense of line? He also did not have a very good group of skilled players around him. I suspect an improved line and skill players, and the reset of a new off season will help him. I expect him to be a solid quarterback next year. Quote
Joe Zura Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago 9 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said: I'm not sure having a foot injury that required surgery is quitting on a team. He actually tried to play with a foot issue, and it ended up making it worse. We'll see how it finishes for him in 2026, but he's playing for Lane Kiffin with his talent and playmaking ... I'm betting he has a very good season. His biggest issue for me is his brother trying to get in agent business, and what that creates in a negative way. He needs to block out that noise, and go focus solely on ball. Thanks for that I did not know any of that. Hopefully he can block out the noise 🫡🫡 Quote
Dawson Yarbrough Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago There are more questions than answers with this group. Lots of new starters. Lots returning starters coming back from injury. How will they look post surgery? Will Arch take another step in his development? Do Chambliss and Stockton pick up where they left off? There’s always a year 1 starter who blows everyone away. Maybe Keelon Russell from Bama? too many questions to try and rank them. BUT the fun part is seeing how it all unfolds through spring and fall camps and eventually through the season. Hookem. Quote
Joe Zura Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago I’m interested in sellers hopefully he can have a bounce back year 1 Quote
Moderators Gerry Hamilton Posted 1 hour ago Author Moderators Posted 1 hour ago 8 minutes ago, Joe Zura said: I’m interested in sellers hopefully he can have a bounce back year I bet he does. Kendal Briles will be really good for him IMO ... if their OL is better. But part of the scheme masks OL very well 2 Quote
Joe Zura Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago 1 minute ago, Gerry Hamilton said: I bet he does. Kendal Briles will be really good for him IMO ... if their OL is better. But part of the scheme masks OL very well Gerry I promised my wife I wouldn’t crash out today and only be happy and troll you but you are making it hard when you mention OL 1 Quote
Assistant Regional Manager Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago (edited) I’m not exactly sure what Missouri’s plan was at QB but I do not feel like they significantly upgraded from what they had when everyone was healthy in 2025. I’m surprised Tennessee didn’t bring in a transfer Jared Curtis is going to have a tough welcome to the SEC with what Vandy lost at the skill spots. Edited 1 hour ago by Assistant Regional Manager Quote
Rocky P Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago 1 minute ago, Joe Zura said: Gerry I promised my wife I wouldn’t crash out today and only be happy and troll you but you are making it hard when you mention OL 4 Quote
diegozanna20 Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago (edited) Arch Manning, Texas (Kind of a 1.b, how much does Arch improve year 2?) *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Gunnar Stockton, Georgia LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina John Mateer, Oklahoma Sam Leavitt, LSU Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Austin Simmons, Missouri Haven't really played: Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtis, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama Edited 1 hour ago by diegozanna20 Quote
JMarquette Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago 39 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said: I'm not sure having a foot injury that required surgery is quitting on a team. He actually tried to play with a foot issue, and it ended up making it worse. We'll see how it finishes for him in 2026, but he's playing for Lane Kiffin with his talent and playmaking ... I'm betting he has a very good season. His biggest issue for me is his brother trying to get in agent business, and what that creates in a negative way. He needs to block out that noise, and go focus solely on ball. I heard that when Lanning asked Dillingham about Leavitt, Dillingham was pretty negative. Quote
JMarquette Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago Just now, diegozanna20 said: Arch Manning, Texas *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Gunnar Stockton, Georgia John Mateer, Oklahoma LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Sam Leavitt, LSU Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky Austin Simmons, Missouri George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtin, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama Swap Trinidad and Arch Swap Mateer and Reed Philo above Jackson Quote
diegozanna20 Posted 1 hour ago Posted 1 hour ago (edited) 3 minutes ago, JMarquette said: Swap Trinidad and Arch Swap Mateer and Reed Philo above Jackson The list you replied to I posted on accident lol, updated it now Don't think it's clear cut that Chambliss is a better college QB than Arch. He has a lot more experience playing than Arch. How does Arch look year 2? Edited 1 hour ago by diegozanna20 Quote
diegozanna20 Posted 51 minutes ago Posted 51 minutes ago 6 minutes ago, diegozanna20 said: Arch Manning, Texas (Kind of a 1.b, how much does Arch improve year 2?) *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Gunnar Stockton, Georgia LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina John Mateer, Oklahoma Sam Leavitt, LSU Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Austin Simmons, Missouri Haven't really played: Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtis, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama My reasoning: Arch Manning -> Not turnover prone, limited experience last year, upward development trajectory, mechanical issues that can be worked on, better supporting cast next year. Complete toolbox that at times wasn't even utilized that much last year. Can scrable, can run, can sit in the pocket and pick you apart. *Trinidad Chambliss -> Really good, pretty experienced already so how much can he improve? He does not have the same physical traits that someone like Arch has. Can still be the better college QB on this list but I got faith in our guy. Gunnar Stockton -> Incredibly high floor, very reliable, can do everything a Georgia offense would ask him to do, Georgia has won with much worse players at QB. Underrated. LaNorris Sellers -> Can make magic happen, if he gets better as a passer can shoot up this list. Beautiful moonball. John Mateer -> Accuracy issues. Gamer. Sam Leavitt -> Can make wow plays and can make incredibly head scratching plays. Gonna miss time due to injury. How does he fare against SEC defenses? Byrum Brown -> I'm probably underrating him. Very talented. KJ Jackson -> Very impressed from what we've seen last year against Texas... but then again we sucked at defending the pass. Again, probably underrating him based on name recognition. Marcel Reed -> Turnover prone, very limited toolbox, not big enough or talented enough to be that unrefined as a passer, gets in his head after making bad plays. Austin Simmons -> Turnover prone, gets in his head after making bad plays, long baseball-like release. Not a lot of experience. Can definitely shoot up next year. 1 Quote
Bunk Moreland Posted 40 minutes ago Posted 40 minutes ago (edited) 1 hour ago, Gerry Hamilton said: Ranking the SEC QB's: OTF community Wanted to see how everyone in the OTF community would rank the SEC QB's post portal and coaching changes... Arch Manning, Texas *Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Sam Leavitt, LSU Gunnar Stockton, Georgia John Mateer, Oklahoma LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina Kamario Taylor, Mississippi State Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Byrum Brown, Auburn KJ Jackson, Arkansas Aaron Philo, Florida Kenny Minchey, Kentucky Austin Simmons, Missouri George MacIntyre, Tennessee Jared Curtin, Vanderbilt Keelon Russell, Alabama Chambliss, Stockton, Manning, Sellers, Leavitt, Brown, Reed, Simmons, Mateer, Jackson. The rest are TBD because I have no idea at this point. The caveat is that Arch might be #1 by the end of the season. Edited 39 minutes ago by Bunk Moreland Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.