Skip to content

Gerry, your commentary on a third loss…

Featured Replies

Is confusing. I’m not saying I disagree but….

let’s assume a third loss. You are saying a 3rd loss to a good team (LSU) is better than a fifth win over a top 25 opponent with a third loss to a “bad” team. I’m not so sure about that.

A loss is a loss. Texas has more “quality” wins than anyone in the country. How can you ignore those regardless of who the 3rd loss comes from.

**caveat, i put nothing past the committee.

  • Moderators
30 minutes ago, Orngblud05 said:

Is confusing. I’m not saying I disagree but….

let’s assume a third loss. You are saying a 3rd loss to a good team (LSU) is better than a fifth win over a top 25 opponent with a third loss to a “bad” team. I’m not so sure about that.

A loss is a loss. Texas has more “quality” wins than anyone in the country. How can you ignore those regardless of who the 3rd loss comes from.

**caveat, i put nothing past the committee.

I wouldn't want to have 3 losses not non-playoff contenders, and go on hope I get in the CFP ... can't lost to one of the two bad teams left and feel good

I believe the only three loss team in the playoffs this year will be either a B10 or SEC team whose third loss is in their CCG.

39 minutes ago, pinkman_90 said:

Are our losses to ou and Florida that bad right now? Both seem like they will finish 8-4 and maybe ranked

I agree that both of those teams are much better than the narrative around them. Put Florida in the Big 10 and they are their 4-5th best team. They were the belle of the ball 2 weeks before we played them and a top 10 team.

Also, I don't like the whole "judge teams how they are now" rather than when we played them. Ohio State was #1 in the country when we beat them. Just because they are losing games now shouldn't make that not a #1 win. If they weren't good at the time then why were they ranked #1?

Not saying that's what you are doing at all btw, just wanting to get those thoughts out there.

It seems like people use current performance for older games when it helps their narrative and then don't when it hurts. I say we just pick one and stick to it: What was the team when we played them. Ole Miss was a top 10 team when we beat them. It shouldn't become an unranked win now that they are dropping games with nothing left to play for.

  • Author
29 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said:

I wouldn't want to have 3 losses not non-playoff contenders, and go on hope I get in the CFP ... can't lost to one of the two bad teams left and feel good

I agree with that. Don’t put it to chance. I’m just questioning your comment that said likely in with a 3rd loss if it’s LSU but not in with a 3rd loss to ark or a&m.

while it’s debatable I’m sure, I would value a good win over a bad loss.

It's a committee of humans. Losing later hurts more. We're supposed to be near our best at the end of the season. Losing to a sub .500 team over the final two games would be lethal.

37 minutes ago, Oldest Horn said:

I believe the only three loss team in the playoffs this year will be either a B10 or SEC team whose third loss is in their CCG.

Yep, completely agree. As much as this surprises me from just two weeks ago, there won’t be an at-large team with 3 regular season losses. Even if it’s Texas.

Wake Forest at 11-1 steals a Playoff spot, and the Big 12 will get at least 2 teams into the Playoffs (possibly 3).

Texas would be the most likely team with 3 regular season losses to make the Playoffs, but I don’t even think that can happen at this point.

Rankings at kickoff matter, but the committee has always leaned on the full body of work by December. Otherwise early polls would end up carrying way too much weight. Rankings at kickoff matter, but the committee always seems to lean on the final résumé anyway. A win over a team that later slides is still better than pretending the game never happened.
15 hours ago, Battrayal said:

I agree that both of those teams are much better than the narrative around them. Put Florida in the Big 10 and they are their 4-5th best team. They were the belle of the ball 2 weeks before we played them and a top 10 team.

Also, I don't like the whole "judge teams how they are now" rather than when we played them. Ohio State was #1 in the country when we beat them. Just because they are losing games now shouldn't make that not a #1 win. If they weren't good at the time then why were they ranked #1?

Not saying that's what you are doing at all btw, just wanting to get those thoughts out there.

It seems like people use current performance for older games when it helps their narrative and then don't when it hurts. I say we just pick one and stick to it: What was the team when we played them. Ole Miss was a top 10 team when we beat them. It shouldn't become an unranked win now that they are dropping games with nothing left to play for.

Analyzing ranking tiers and strength-of-schedule metrics always puts me in a mindset of evaluating value and rewards across different platforms. When looking into online gaming and sports entertainment accounts, I prefer setups that offer high-tier benefits and solid loyalty programs. I was actually reading a comparison site that breaks down the best online VIP casino programs for Canadian players to see how their reward structures compare. Their evaluation of top online casino VIP programs in Canada gave a really solid breakdown of payout speeds, dedicated account managers, and exclusive tier perks. I also came across the best vip online casinos guide on PlayVIPCasino, which offers a useful overview of these programs.

Rankings at kickoff matter, but the committee has always leaned on the full body of work by December. Otherwise early polls would end up carrying way too much weight. Rankings at kickoff matter, but the committee always seems to lean on the final résumé anyway. A win over a team that later slides is still better than pretending the game never happened.

Edited by tamerivet96

The abnormality is every team that was supposed to either really challenge or beat Texas, Texas has found a way to win. Those games that they should have won without issue are the ones they lost. I get the OU game as the RRR tou can throw out the records but Florida again is head scratching. So as bad as the losses are the wins are equally as good. Thats what makes me nervous these last 2 games. Texas should handily win both of these games. With that said all of the Texas opponents have a better than .500 record except Miss St, Arkansas and ATM.

Edited by watty7796

2 minutes ago, Gerry Hamilton said:

It is a what have you done for me lately situation though is some ways I understand why. Teams that make the CFP should be demonstrating a definitive upward trend from beginning of season to end. If you arent getting better or injuries obviously hamstring your ability to compete ( Fl St) why be in the CFP. This is also why I dont agree with the non P4 and ND exceptions. If they are competitive great. If they show up and get trounced by 50 its not good for college football and its not good for that particular college either.

Sub beating Florida and losing at lsu. Ou rivalry and a loss on the road against a loaded lsu team at night are “plausible and understandable” to anyone that even basically understands football. It makes sense those can be losses. It’s explainable. At home against Florida or Arkansas is inexcusable. Arkansas really hurts with a loss to them at home. Aggie could as well but it’s a road game and most people mistakenly believe they are this monster at home that is hugely talented but under achieving. I think an aggie loss hurts but doesn’t destroy us and puts it as a coin flip. Losses to ou, fl, and ar, 2 at home, were very likely out. A loss has to “make sense” in order for the committee to slide us in.

Edited by Thanos72

20 hours ago, Oldest Horn said:

I believe the only three loss team in the playoffs this year will be either a B10 or SEC team whose third loss is in their CCG.

I agree with this. If you look at it ranking in the AP, we are 8. A third loss to an unranked team would put us once again in the mid teens, and as we saw last year the CPC took that ranking and record into account when the slotted us 2 slots outside the playoffs. They kept mentioning the loss to Florida.

Agreed, but Texas just has to not beat Texas in those games. IMHO a loss to either is detrimental as they will be the 2nd and 3rd teams Texas will play with a loosing record. Through the rest of the schedule only Miss St was below 500

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.