I agree to disagree. You make a valid point, but a lot of QBs have thrown interceptions 1st year, see Peyton Manning, Colt McCoy or even VY. Especially since Mack (spellcheck) changed to an entirely new offense (mistake in my opinion and I thought so at the time). Don’t get me wrong, incredibly thankful for Mack and his service to the university, great man and leader of men, but that was an overreaction to losing to Alabama I think, and a mistake. And as far as Gilbert is concerned, I just feel like he could have been coached up into the new system and given a little more time. Mack is a good enough talker he could have sold it and kept his job. He was also one year removed from being in the national championship, he was safe. And Case and Ash were not better, see NFL career.