Skip to content

Film Breakdown: Coach Collins

Featured Replies

48 minutes ago, Bobby Burton said:

Playing fast.

A lot of the chat was upset with the defense most of the night. I think the 4th Q showed exactly why Sark wanted Muschamp. When it was crunch time and we needed that ball back, repeatedly, we got it.

Also Champ is doing this with a team that aren’t his players. I think the fact that he tailored this to what he had in the room is what really sets him apart from other coaches.

Yes, Muschamp is the unsung hero. I do hope there is an honest accounting of the offense after the season. Sark should not be the one doing the assessment.

  1. Do we want Arch Manning to return next year?

  2. How has our O Line become so poor, and who is responsible?

  3. What is a WR centric offense? Why would we spend money on Cam Coleman instead of a competent OL? This has been a recurring theme under Sark.

  4. After 4 years in the Texas system, Arch struggles to locate and throw to receivers quickly. Why?

I can't even imagine being a quarterback. There is too much information to process, and meanwhile there are fire breathing big guys trying to kill you. No thanks.

That's some really good stuff from Coach Collins. I really appreciate the way he breaks things down. He brings a perspective that goes beyond simply looking at the scoreboard and pointing fingers.

I think Muschamp deserves a ton of credit. He's working with players he didn't recruit, adapting to the talent he inherited, and finding ways to put them in positions to succeed. Whatever complaints we had about the defense earlier in the game, when it was crunch time and we needed stops, they delivered. That's coaching.

Now I'd like to see that same level of progress on the offensive side. The offensive line, Arch's development, receiver utilization and play-calling all deserve an honest evaluation. We have too much talent on that side of the ball to continue struggling the way we have.

Collins makes some excellent points, and I hope we're paying attention. There's a lot to build on defensively. Now let's figure out how to get this offense on the same page. 🤘

7 hours ago, Grant Ward said:

Yes, Muschamp is the unsung hero. I do hope there is an honest accounting of the offense after the season. Sark should not be the one doing the assessment.

  1. Do we want Arch Manning to return next year?

  2. How has our O Line become so poor, and who is responsible?

  3. What is a WR centric offense? Why would we spend money on Cam Coleman instead of a competent OL? This has been a recurring theme under Sark.

  4. After 4 years in the Texas system, Arch struggles to locate and throw to receivers quickly. Why?

Fair points, especially about OL. That is going to keep us from achieving our ultimate goal if it continues. I think we absolutely do want Arch to come back. Here’s why IMO, he is a winner and what he is experiencing this year is an NFL like schedule and defenses that bring multiple looks and have speed/talent all over. All that with a very porous and confused line. It’s better that he’s seeing it and developing now because he won’t have that luxury in the NFL. Despite his struggles he is progressing and is able to win while getting better. What he needs next year is a competent o line so he can take that next step into dominating. But he’s been the offense the last 2 years and he needs to be able to turn and have the ball off consistently. Once we have that (and when we have had it at times this season) we’ll really see the development and lethality of his talent. Better for him to have one more year in college than to jump to the NFL and get pummeled there. I honestly believe he’s much closer to being a top QB than most. No doubt he’s struggled with a lot the last two years but he’s also seen a TON and come out victorious way more than just about anyone else. He’s just not as polished as we expect a Manning to be, but that’s ok it doesn’t mean he can’t be or won’t be. One more year with Arch!! I’d like to see Cam, Moseley, and bishop in this offense next year with a little more continuity and consistency. We need Cam to actually play the WR position not just run deep. That’s a key element to Arch’s struggles imo is that it seems like he’s forcing the ball to Cam instead of letting the ball find the open man as Sark has described his offense. That’s what WR centric means to me.

28 minutes ago, Alex Butler said:

Fair points, especially about OL. That is going to keep us from achieving our ultimate goal if it continues. I think we absolutely do want Arch to come back. Here’s why IMO, he is a winner and what he is experiencing this year is an NFL like schedule and defenses that bring multiple looks and have speed/talent all over. All that with a very porous and confused line. It’s better that he’s seeing it and developing now because he won’t have that luxury in the NFL. Despite his struggles he is progressing and is able to win while getting better. What he needs next year is a competent o line so he can take that next step into dominating. But he’s been the offense the last 2 years and he needs to be able to turn and have the ball off consistently. Once we have that (and when we have had it at times this season) we’ll really see the development and lethality of his talent. Better for him to have one more year in college than to jump to the NFL and get pummeled there. I honestly believe he’s much closer to being a top QB than most. No doubt he’s struggled with a lot the last two years but he’s also seen a TON and come out victorious way more than just about anyone else. He’s just not as polished as we expect a Manning to be, but that’s ok it doesn’t mean he can’t be or won’t be. One more year with Arch!! I’d like to see Cam, Moseley, and bishop in this offense next year with a little more continuity and consistency. We need Cam to actually play the WR position not just run deep. That’s a key element to Arch’s struggles imo is that it seems like he’s forcing the ball to Cam instead of letting the ball find the open man as Sark has described his offense. That’s what WR centric means to me.

Without Muschamp and this defense, we are Texas A&M. I don't this offense gets a pass without this D. Look at the multitude of OC's and QB"s being replaced for lack of performance. Sark and Arch's numbers are not good. Is it time t9 go back to the wishbone to beat the 3 high safeties defense?

10 hours ago, Bobby Burton said:

Good stuff here from Coach Geoff Collins.

Bigger Appreciation for Arch!

I wonder how many millions of $$$ extra were spent by defensive staffs to get to Arch- confuse him … sack him … intercept

OSU

LSU ( oranda)

Tennessee

Ou

FL

Missouri

You literally got entire paid cosching staffs gunning for his loss!

I wanna play Georgia! Just to liberate those demons!

Edited by Joe Naural

I really appreciate the way he presents the information. Easy to listen to and explanations are clear and to the point. He doesn't waste time explaining the same play over and over again like some YouTube analysts.

4 hours ago, Grant Ward said:

Without Muschamp and this defense, we are Texas A&M. I don't this offense gets a pass without this D. Look at the multitude of OC's and QB"s being replaced for lack of performance. Sark and Arch's numbers are not good. Is it time t9 go back to the wishbone to beat the 3 high safeties defense?

You’re 100% right about that, Arch would be great at the wishbone one with Terry, Brown, and Cooper in the backfield…

7 hours ago, OTF12024 said:

I really appreciate the way he presents the information. Easy to listen to and explanations are clear and to the point. He doesn't waste time explaining the same play over and over again like some YouTube analysts.

Like our Rod B.

No rambling on and on crap

17 hours ago, HookEm said:

Also Champ is doing this with a team that aren’t his players. I think the fact that he tailored this to what he had in the room is what really sets him apart from other coaches.

It wasn't like Champ walked into a room full of bad players.

8 hours ago, Grant Ward said:

Without Muschamp and this defense, we are Texas A&M. I don't this offense gets a pass without this D. Look at the multitude of OC's and QB"s being replaced for lack of performance. Sark and Arch's numbers are not good. Is it time t9 go back to the wishbone to beat the 3 high safeties defense?

The wishbone? 😂 At this rate, we might need Darrell Royal's playbook, Earl Campbell in the backfield, and a prayer. Maybe start by blocking somebody before we reinvent football!

I'm not ready to bring back the wishbone just yet. Although, with our offensive line, at least we'd have three backs to help with the blocking! 😂

17 hours ago, Grant Ward said:

Yes, Muschamp is the unsung hero. I do hope there is an honest accounting of the offense after the season. Sark should not be the one doing the assessment.

  1. Do we want Arch Manning to return next year?

  2. How has our O Line become so poor, and who is responsible?

  3. What is a WR centric offense? Why would we spend money on Cam Coleman instead of a competent OL? This has been a recurring theme under Sark.

  4. After 4 years in the Texas system, Arch struggles to locate and throw to receivers quickly. Why?

1) No, if we have the same OL, TE, and QB coaches. We get nothing out of that and he doesn't improve. If Sark stays with the same offensive coaching battery, then Arch needs to move on to get new teaching. If, however, Sark gets an OC/QB-coach, new OL coach, and TE coach, then he has a definite reason to return to get new coaching. Especially, is Sark hits a homerun like he did with Muschamp.

2) The OL issues are all on Flood. The Film Guy has said for 2 years that our OL are still making freshmen mistakes year 4 in the system and at the end of the season in a bowl game.

3) Think an air raid spread offense with 4 WRs always in pattern, and a RB as an outlet. They pass to set up the runs, draws, and check downs. Cam Coleman was paid to help our red zone struggles.

4) You have to question Sark's and Milwee's ability to develop a QB. Even Ewers struggled to maximize his talents. Sark needs new blood on that side of the ball.

Edited by mmdaytontexas

I coached my twin boys first football tackling experience when they were 8. I had a kid who was super fast named Grayson. My entire offense was Grayson gets the ball and runs as fast as he can. 😁

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.