Skip to content

ESPN ranking all P4 QB's

Featured Replies

Is this the Bill Connelly one? I'm sorry but that guy is a rube. His opinion is and analysis pieces were always a joke, but at one point his SP+ model was at least one of the better predictive models that was publicly available.

Since the transfer portal / NIL / AI became a thing SP+ is quite unremarkable as well. FPI consistently beats SP+ at predicting against the spread.

Interesting that both Levitt’s red zone interceptions and Arch’s 4th qtr play and game-winning drives were both almost throw away comments that don’t really matter. Watching the game last week having those two QB’s 20 spots apart from each other in the rankings is unexplainable.

1 hour ago, pskjace said:

Interesting that both Levitt’s red zone interceptions and Arch’s 4th qtr play and game-winning drives were both almost throw away comments that don’t really matter. Watching the game last week having those two QB’s 20 spots apart from each other in the rankings is unexplainable.

Just shows the biased or hate versus one goes to show most of these probably don’t even watch all of the games. They take highlights and social media perception and make their lists just for clicks

1 minute ago, MBHORNSFAN said:

Based on overall play for the year Arch is not a top 20 QB...

NFL doesn’t draft you solely on “what you can do as a rookie”.

They draft for long term, potential abilities and I bet there is enough for the pro coaches to look at and think they can build him up and give him the develop he needs to have a long career. Whether that’s as a backup or starter only time will tell but I think he has the foundation to get drafted and might surprise some people in the long run

1 minute ago, SB21 said:

NFL doesn’t draft you solely on “what you can do as a rookie”.

They draft for long term, potential abilities and I bet there is enough for the pro coaches to look at and think they can build him up and give him the develop he needs to have a long career. Whether that’s as a backup or starter only time will tell but I think he has the foundation to get drafted and might surprise some people in the long run

I really do not care how NFL ranks him or how he does in the NFL. All I care about is how he performs here while he is here.

There had to be some anti-Texas bias in that ranking. There is no way in the hell Arch ranks behind some of those QBs at #35. Many are scrubs and backups forced to play. Arch has struggled for sure, especially with his putrid OL, but his ability is light years better than many of those QBs listed above him in that ranking.

Edited by mmdaytontexas

Ouch. I think it has a lot to do with his hype and expectation versus how he's actually performing. Which by the way wasn't his fault. I think they are off with ranking him that low but the reasoning for not having him in the top 20 is reasonable. Arch has been wildly inconsistent but it doesn't all fall on him. Having a historically bad OLine has played a big role in his play this season.

12 minutes ago, MBHORNSFAN said:

I really do not care how NFL ranks him or how he does in the NFL. All I care about is how he performs here while he is here.

That’s fair. It’s not like the dude has done terrible. He’s won a lot of games and has struggled sure but who doesn’t struggle in college playing a bunch of top 25 teams every year. Sometimes expectations make the pressure so much harder on these kids. So to say he isn’t a “top 20 qb” is based on what? His struggles? Or his overall production against what he has had to play against?

Which QB’s are “better” or have had better numbers…… to push Arch out of your top 20?

I have zero issue with where these "pundits" want to rank Arch. He's better at 35 than in the top 10. I care how he performs and he's winning crucial games for us (obviously not taking anything away from the defense or special teams who are the reason Arch is able to try and win games). He doesn't need more pressure . . . if he needs anything - and i'm not sure he does at at this point - its fuel for the fire.

11 minutes ago, SB21 said:

That’s fair. It’s not like the dude has done terrible. He’s won a lot of games and has struggled sure but who doesn’t struggle in college playing a bunch of top 25 teams every year. Sometimes expectations make the pressure so much harder on these kids. So to say he isn’t a “top 20 qb” is based on what? His struggles? Or his overall production against what he has had to play against?

Which QB’s are “better” or have had better numbers…… to push Arch out of your top 20?

I get that but are we winning because of Arch or because of the talent around him? I am not sure we would have the same record right now with a lot of QB and we are likely 10-0 with a better QB.

22 minutes ago, MBHORNSFAN said:

I get that but are we winning because of Arch or because of the talent around him? I am not sure we would have the same record right now with a lot of QB and we are likely 10-0 with a better QB.

Thats an easy “what if” conversation right. Yes I agree Arch being off cost us some points here and there. Yes his turnovers hurt us from time to time like the Oklahoma int at the end or the fumbles.

but we can’t base the theory that we would have won “with someone else” cause what if they too made mistakes. Worse mistakes even. lol too many variables to assume we would be 10-0.

LSU and Ole Miss surely didn’t expect their season to go the way it has and both have QB’s that at the start of the season were among “the best or highly touted QB’s”

Look at Josh Hoover at Indiana. Benched. No one would have predicted that right?

the ball bounces our way or it doesn’t sometimes. Great calls by coordinators change games. Players getting hurt or simply making mistakes happen and changes games. I just find it hard to put on Arch that we lost games cause of him and would be 10-0 if we had a different qb

Second Season for Colt McCoy vs Arch Manning’s second season stats. Yes it’s been rough at times but, it hasn’t been all doom and gloom.

Statistic Colt McCoy (2007) Arch Manning (2026) Colts stats on the left Arch on the right.

Games played 13 10

Completions 276 187

Attempts 424 289

Completion % 65.1% 64.7%

Passing yards 3,303 2,198

Passing TDs 22 19

Interceptions 18 10

Yards per attempt 7.8 7.6

Passer rating 139.2 143.4

Rushing yards 492 154

Rushing TDs 4 3

Total TDs 26 22

Gerry Hamilton seems happy to post/say negative stuff regarding Arch and it makes me tired. Watching the "big game" last week against OK State, the Tech QB throws to wide open receivers against Big12 DBs and Big12 pass rushes with throws that would be intercepted literally every time against SEC defenses. The idea he is rated above Arch is really something no one seriously evaluating would believe. Arch is a long way from perfect, but come on.

just go 2 min offense the entire first half…. Beginning of 2 nd half… he needs to air it out… … dhort game … long game . We win natl championship by not playing safe … turn Arch looose agaisnt ark and A&m

We win this by 30 plus!

You cant run Arch at Idle at this stage of his career development. This kids needs grass stains … bloood dripping from elbow…running - slamming - shifting gears.

Go wide open w him …. You gotta blow out the black shoot in carbeurator…. He will run smooth.

No all jeeps … trucks run the same!

Go wide open …. Stretch defense vertical - horizontal …. Then let Michael Terry -Cooper - Simon slash/ dash n pound

Save Ralek for cfp light load til it matters.

Edited by Joe Naural

If you’re triggered by arch being ranked that low then you must have not paid much attention to his play this year. I think he’ll be best suited to come back for his senior year and HOPE sarks for the balls to make a change at the offensive line coach position.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.