Everything posted by ArizonaLonghorn
-
PFF IS GARBAGE FOR THIS
I also wondered about the numbers, the sheer tonnage of data they collect and analyze in such a short time, so I dug into it a bit. 138 FBS teams and these are graded first. So a max # of 138 games if each played the same day against a non-FBS team (which is unlikely, but a hard ceiling). 69 games if all 138 played other FBS teams but there are usually a few teams with bye weeks or the games are spread across different days. And the games are spread across 3 or 4 viewing windows during the day so they can finish say an early game while the 2nd window game plays, then work on the evening game. So probably need roughly half as many graders as games played on the busiest day. You ask "Do they employ 1000+ skilled tape watchers?" Check this PFF Player Grades link (free), scroll down to the "Who is doing the Grading?" block and it says they have "600 full or part-time analysts, but less than 10% of analysts are trained to the level that they can grade plays. " So 60-ish graders and another 9-10 support guys per grader. What do the support guys do? I guess they do the grunt work of chopping up the videos so the grader can simply grade, maybe IDing players and formations, breaking plays down into run vs pass etc. I've exchanged messages with a guy who works part time for PFF and he said he was responsible for one task on every play - with multiple guys doing this it would free up a grader to simply evaluate by position. How much actual time is taken up by active plays in a 60 minute game? I've heard 12-15 minutes, surely less than 20 minutes. So if the All-22 is broken down right they can probably grade two games a day. You mention "100 total players in each game" but they would only do 22 per play and somewhere in that link I gave you it says most plays grade as neutral for most of the players so they can probably rip thru it pretty fast. I was skeptical at first but I can see how they can pull it off. Hope this helps. Not trying to carry water for PFF, just trying to understand it better. This was something I dug into a little (I had the same concerns you raise) and now I can see how it makes sense that they could do it that quickly with 60 trained graders. Whether you agree with their ranking results is a different topic.
-
PFF IS GARBAGE FOR THIS
From the free side of their site (I think) - "How PFF grades pass protection". Not what might seem intuitive to the casual viewer like me, but it's worth understanding what and why they are doing even if you disagree. I just started a subscription to PFF earlier this year and am still learning how they grade ... it's frustrating at times but usually there's a method to their madness.
-
PFF IS GARBAGE FOR THIS
Far too nuanced for your average Fan Site Expert, alas! Burn it down!
-
Gabe Ikard: Texas defense is ‘better than Georgia’s’
I agree we have a much better team than OU. They looked comically inept at times vs Georgia. But they hate us and will likely come out against us fully focused, angry and embarrassed, with a few tricks up their sleeves. if we are overconfident or caught looking ahead to Florida and LSU or a little flat - well it’s hard to imagine us losing but it will take longer to finish them off. Us old timers remember big games we should have won and didn’t. My worst memory as a fan was the year we went undefeated in the regular season, ranked unanimous # 1, had the Heisman and Outland Trophy winners plus Coach of the Year. Sports Illustrated posed the question “Is Texas the best college team ever?” We ate the rat poison and came out flat, fumbled several times and got crushed in the Cotton Bowl.
-
Gabe Ikard: Texas defense is ‘better than Georgia’s’
Rat poison
-
Some tweets
Are Aggies extending Elko if they cover the spread?
-
Snap Judgments: No. 1 Texas rides historic defensive performance to road win over No. 14 Tennessee, 20-17
God might forgive Colin but 10% of the OTF subscribers apparently never will.
-
Snap Judgments: No. 1 Texas rides historic defensive performance to road win over No. 14 Tennessee, 20-17
He got banged up (I think on the INT) and it looked like they were screening for possible concussion. Bishop played well in his place
-
OTF has some explaining to do
And sports gambling, you can take credit for that too Bobby !
-
R’Monie Edwards to Tech Prediction
Tech seems willing to pay well-over market value when they ID a guy they really want. Recent examples include transfer edge David Bailey, whose offer was triple what most schools offered, and 5* OT recruit Felix Ojo. Supposedly Ojo was offered $5.1 million for 3 years even though he will most likely sit and “develop” for 1-2 years, and he was embarrassed by good edge rushers at camps before his senior season. No idea what the deal is with Edwards but that’s been the recent trend
-
College Football Live Thread: Week 3
Right on cue INT
-
Big 10 school making all athletics free to Students
USC is supposedly considering PAYING students $50 to attend football games when the temperature is over 90 degrees. Those thousands of empty seats are an embarrassment.
-
Anthony Hill Jr. leads the NFL in tackles through Week 1
How does this compare to his last season at Texas? (Stats from PFF) 12 tackles vs Kentucky (best game for tackles) 8 tackles vs Florida (2nd best game) 3 (!!!) tackles vs Ohio State (7th best game)
-
The Ones Who Got Away
Nice symmetry - the Texas kicker is an Ohio native who made the winning kick while the Ohio State kicker is a Texas native who missed the likely game-clinching 45 yard FG.
-
Dan Lanning Resigns After Oregon Loss
What does Dan Lanning have to do with it?
-
Portal Hidden Gems
Not exactly a hidden gem but I've been very pleased with Melvin Siani's play. We have two dominant tackles now, plus Baker gets to plug the hole at guard.
-
Hi
Gerry said football about mid-way on the first page
-
Hi
Guessing ... [Edit: oops! Too soon?]
-
Things I’m happy to admit I was wrong about
TL;DR
-
Favorite comedians?
Tim Conway with a couple of sketches on the Carol Burnett Show. The Dentist was great. Dorf playing golf. Here's The Elephant story, a classic - backstory, Tim used to bug the hell out of his fellow actors by following the script during rehearsal and then free lancing during the live take, which is what he did here. He had a single one word line "elephant" in the script but then when tangential in front of the audience... this explains the ending better. (The Dentist is even funnier but somewhat longer)
-
Officiating for 2027 Mich game
Guessing the Monster Energy Big 12 would be very happy to lend us a crew of their ace refs ...
-
Penalties-Yesterday OSU vs. Texas
From PFF data 4 pens offense, all on OL 2 RG VanSickle in 43 snaps, 1 each RG Cook (28 snaps), LT Lowe (28 snaps) 3 pens defense one each free safety, right end (or edge?), RT 2 pens ST (not clear on this, says 2(1) which I would assume meant 2 penalties called, one accepted, but then you'd be short a penalty if they actually had 9 for the game) Anyway you were right about the OL having issues, especially at RG. Good!
-
UNC……get your popcorn
Is one of these dudes wearing a toupee ?
-
Cody Campbell is BIG MAD … says Tech will run up the score
I mostly heard the "my interactions with him have been positive" and "he's a good guy" about Joey McGuire, dating back to his high school coaching days. I think Jordan, Jeff and maybe Gerry said things similar to this, could be wrong though. Can't remember anyone here actually standing up for Cody Campbell
-
Dream World - What team do you wish Texas would schedule?
Yes for ASU game - I could actually attend that one easily enough, I'm just two miles from the Tempe border lol. ASU is a decent team in a P4 conference under Kenny D, so helps our SOS, but no real threat to beat Texas if Texas shows up ready to go.